> Skip to content

Article  •  12 May 2016

 

The trenches of hell

Peter FitzSimons illuminates the horrific WW1 battles of Fromelles and Pozières.

The Australian War Memorial describes the first 24 hours of battle at Fromelles, France, as ‘not the worst in Australian military history, the worst 24 hours in Australia's entire history.’ Yet the story of the carnage at Fromelles and, days later, at Pozières is lesser known than other stories of Australian military history.

Peter FitzSimons writes in Fromelles and Pozières: In the Trenches of Hell:

‘And now the Australians . . . are hit by thunder and lightning and shells and machine-gun bullets all together! For, in an instant, a blasting blizzard of lead tears across No-Man’s Land and into the heads, torsos and legs of the charging Australians...

‘In the end, the Battle of the Somme, which was ended by the exhaustion of both sides in the winter of 1916–17, was most staggering both for its catastrophic slaughter – with the forces of the British Empire, the French and the Germans losing over 1.1 million soldiers, killed and wounded between them – and for how little those deaths translated into advances or retreats.’

FitzSimons’ book provides a stirring account that brings the battles back to life and puts the reader in the moment, illustrating both the heroism displayed and the insanity of the British plan. As very brief background, consider these facts about a story to make all Australians proud – and angry.

  • Australia’s first entry to World War One’s main battle theatre in Europe is marked by the battles of Fromelles (19-20 July, 1916) and Pozières (23 July-7August, 1916). The Battle of Fromelles was the first major battle fought by Australian troops (5th Australian Division) on the Western Front.
  • In the first 24 hours at Fromelles, the Australians suffered 5,533 casualties. Almost 2,000 were killed in action or died later from their wounds.
  • In total, the battles of Fromelles and Pozières combined, 8,800 Australians were killed, and casualties numbered 28,533.
  • ‘It was a staggering disaster,’ says the Australian War Memorial website. ‘The dismal culmination of muddled planning and reckless decision making by both British and Australian commanders.’ In the words of W.H. ‘Jimmy’ Downing of the 15th Brigade: ‘Men were cut in two by streams of bullets [that] swept like whirling knives . . .  It was the charge of the Light Brigade once more, but more terrible, more hopeless.’
  • Five Victoria Crosses were awarded to Australians for their actions at Pozières. The Victoria Cross is awarded by the Australian Government for ‘most conspicuous gallantry, or some daring or pre-eminent act of valour or self-sacrifice, or extreme devotion to duty in the presence of the enemy or belligerents.’ In context, 65 Australians were awarded the VC in all of World War One and 20 in World War Two.
  • In the Australian Memorial Park in Fromelles, a statue called ‘Cobbers’ depicts Sergeant Simon Fraser of the 58th Battalion carrying a wounded man on his back. The park’s official literature says, ‘It is not the military disaster of Fromelles remembered here but the courage and compassion of those who risked their lives to help the wounded.’
  • ‘The Windmill’ site at Pozières is today owned by the Australian War Memorial. Historian Charles Bean suggested the purchase because ‘the Windmill site . . . marks a ridge more densely sown with Australian sacrifice than any other place on Earth.’

More features

See all
Article
Fitzy’s top Aussies

Peter FitzSimons shares his top-10 Australian heroes.

Article
Romantasy Recommendations

Wanting to get into reading romantasy but not sure where to start? Read on for our top picks of the genre!

Article
QUIZ: Which Hawthorne brother is your soulmate?

Take this quiz to find out which Hawthorne brother from The Inheritance Games series would be your perfect match.

Article
The Lottie Brooks books, in order

Don’t know which order to read the Lottie Brooks books? Find out which to read first, and learn a little bit about each book.

Article
Your guide to pre-ordering Alchemised

Learn how to pre-order Alchemised by SenLin Yu and join the thousands of readers who will start reading it on 23 September 2025.

Article
Penguin Picks for July: Books we've been loving

Want to know what books the Penguin NZ team have been reading and loving recently? Read on for our recommendations!

Article
Staff recommendations: Books we've been loving

Want to know what books the Penguin NZ team have been reading and loving recently? Read on for our recommendations!

Article
5 of the hottest YA books right now (2025)

Check out some of the hottest YA books in stores now, from epic romantasy to sweet, unexpected romance.

Article
Best historical fiction books to read in 2025

From tales of Ancient Greece to epics set in the Second World War, these are the historical novels at the top of our reading piles this year.

Article
How to save money on groceries: 6 innovative budget tips

Food shopping on a budget? These tips from Money-Saving Meal Plans With Chelsea will help you spend less on food.

Article
20 books like The Let Them Theory

Finished The Let Them Theory and wondering what to read next? Check out this list of 20 suggested picks that will leave you feeling inspired and empowered.

Article
Mother's Day Memories: Penguin Authors

For Mother's Day 2025 we're celebrating the power of books to bring us closer.

Looking for more articles?

See all articles