> Skip to content

Book clubs  •  5 November 2025

 

The Soldier’s Daughter book club questions

From Fiona McIntosh, author of The Fallen Woman, comes this heart-stopping new blockbuster – perfect for reading with your book club. Here are some thought-starters.

In The Soldier’s Daughter by Fiona McIntosh, Violet Nash has grown up in the shadows of her father Charlie’s shattered dreams. It’s been years since he walked away from the battlefields of France as a WWI hero.

In search of a new beginning, they set sail for Tasmania to open a whisky distillery, and Violet shows a rare talent for the art of distilling and blending.

But some secrets cannot be forgotten, and with WWII raging on, Charlie feels a pull to once again play his part. Following him, Violet finds herself straight back in Champagne where open arms, future hopes and past ghosts lie waiting.

Discussion points and questions

  1. ‘I’m tired of fighting, my love. I seem to have done it for a lifetime.’ In what ways has Charlie been fighting all his life?
  2. Of his experience in the war, Charlie declares: ‘I count myself lucky to have survived with a healthy mind.’ In what ways does Violet perceive otherwise?
  3. When Charlie and Violet arrive in Australia, do they find it to be ‘the land of opportunity’ that had been promised?
  4. Do you understand and/or respect Charlie’s motivation for returning to Épernay?
  5. Give me time and love, her whisky replied . . . We could become very good friends.’ Are you a drinker of whisky? What makes it so special?
  6. ‘War makes good people do bad things.’ Discuss in relation to this novel.
  7. Do you agree with Violet’s mother, Ellen, that love is overwhelming? In what ways do we do this idea played out in The Soldier’s Daughter and its prequel, The Champagne War?
  8. Violet wants to hate Raphael, but life has other ideas. What is it about him that attracts her? Do you think he’s a better match for her than John, and why?
  9. The Soldier’s Daughter is full of dramatic moments. Which surprised you the most?
  10. Where do you think Violet feels most at home – England, Scotland, Tasmania or France – and why?
  11. Of Charlie’s many sacrifices, which was the greatest?
  12. ‘Never be a sheep, Violet,’ Charlie had counselled. ‘You may not be popular, and you may unnerve others, but you will always be happier if you stay true to yourself.’ In what ways does Violet heed this advice? Does it lead to happiness?

Feature Title

More features

See all
Book clubs
Blood pact book club questions

Fiona McIntosh's explosive new Jack Hawksworth thriller, perfect to read with your book club.

Book clubs
The Fallen Woman book club questions

A heart-stopping historical adventure to read with your book club.

Book clubs
Foul Play book club questions

A heart-stopping Jack Hawksworth novel to read with your book club.

Book clubs
The Sugar Palace book club questions

A heart-stopping romantic adventure to read with your book club.

Book clubs
The Spy's Wife book club notes

Much loved author Fiona McIntosh is back with an historical adventure to enjoy with your book club.

Book clubs
Mirror Man book club notes

Ponder whether one life is worth more than another with Fiona McIntosh's latest thriller.

Book clubs
The Champagne War book club notes

Sweep your book club off to the sun-kissed vineyards of rural France.

Article
Best historical fiction books to read in 2025

From tales of Ancient Greece to epics set in the Second World War, these are the historical novels at the top of our reading piles this year.

Article
The Penguin Summer Reading Club Chapter Sampler

Dive into our summer reading picks to decide which Penguin (or Penguins) you want to escape with this summer!

Article
Find your next thrill!

Thrill-seekers! After a fast-paced, chilling and unputdownable read?

Q&A
Fiona McIntosh on writing a 'fish out of water' tale

The much-loved author chats to us about researching The Spy's Wife on the cusp of the pandemic starting, studying 1930s German history and baking cherry cakes.

Q&A
Fiona McIntosh on DCI Jack Hawksworth

The bestselling author discusses tapping back into Jack's world, twisty-turny stories and her favourite crime dramas.

Looking for more book club notes?

See all book club notes