> Skip to content

Recipe  •  1 October 2018


Mini fruit mince pie cheesecakes

A combination of two Christmas favourites — fruit mince pies and creamy delicious cheesecake, from Better Than a Bought One.

For me to not feel hard done by, Christmas really must include mince pies. So, I would always have a tin of traditional ones along for the ride. However, the need is very nicely met in this combination of two of my favourites — Christmas mince pies and creamy delicious cheesecake. These freeze beautifully so can be prepared ahead of the season.

Makes: 12 mini cheesecakes | Prep Time: 10 minutes | Cooking Time: 12–15 minutes | Chilling Time: 2 hours



1 cup biscuit crumbs (I use Digestive biscuits)
½ teaspoon mixed spice
75g butter, melted
250g traditional cream cheese (not lite or spreadable) 
½ teaspoon vanilla
1 egg
½ cup caster sugar
½ cup prepared Christmas fruit mince whipped cream or thickened cream to serve
extra ¼ cup fruit mince to serve


Preheat oven to 180°C. Spray a 12-hole mini-cheesecake pan (see Cook’s Tip) with non-stick baking spray. Just spray in the holes of the pan and the bases, not all over the surface of the pan.

Mix the biscuit crumbs, mixed spice and melted butter together. This can be done in a food processor (including crushing the biscuits into crumbs). Divide the mixture amongst the 12 little cups, pressing down firmly. A little round spice jar seems the perfect implement to press in the mixture.

Beat the cream cheese, vanilla, egg and caster sugar together until well mixed. Spoon a teaspoon of mixture into each cup then top with a generous teaspoon of fruit mince. Cover the mince with the remaining cream cheese mixture.

Bake for 12–15 minutes. The cheesecakes will puff up and the tops be golden brown and firm when pressed gently. Remove from the oven and cool. The cheesecakes will sink but don’t worry about this. 
The whole tray needs to be chilled for at least 2 hours or even overnight.

To serve, carefully press the bases and push up the cheesecakes. I usually run the tip of a small sharp knife around the edge to help ease them out. Use the knife to remove the bottom metal base and place on a serving plate. The cheesecakes can be removed to a plastic-covered container and frozen at this stage. I would take them frozen to a picnic and they will be thawed by the time you need to eat them.

Garnish with a dollop of whipped cream and a spoonful of fruit mince.


Mini-cheesecake pans with push-up bases are available in good cookware stores — the compliments the dessert will get you soon outweigh the purchase price of the pan. This piece of kitchen equipment makes cheesecakes and small individual desserts an absolute breeze. I have also used a silicon mini-muffin tray with good success as an alternative.

More features

See all recipes
Cauliflower couscous salad with grilled halloumi

A salad you can prepare ahead for a backyard BBQ, from Better Than a Bought One.

Dried apricots with basil cream cheese & honey roasted almonds

Very popular nibbles that are easy to prepare in advance from Better Than a Bought One.

Cherry cheesecake fudge brownie

Surprisingly easy to make and is the best brownie of all time – gooey and fudgy, not dry and cake-like.

Jo Seagar's simple etiquette tips

Good manners open doors that even the best education can’t. 

Dolly's Hangover Mac and Cheese recipe from Everything I Know About Love

Now that the TV adaptation of Dolly Alderton's iconic memoir is screening on TVNZ, may we suggest you pair your viewing with her totally indulgent mac and cheese recipe from Everything I Know About Love.

Sticky, Spicy Basil Shrimp

I developed a habit of eating the entire shrimp when I was a kid.

Tartara Marshmallow

This light and airy marshmallow beautifully harnesses the natural citrus aroma and flavour that tarata has to offer. Serve them torched, or not – they’re delicious either way.

Speculoos cake

This cake is a must for speculoos biscuit lovers.

Cod with tahini, pine nuts and spinach

I confess that I was seduced by the man who made this dish for me.

Baked rhubarb posset with almonds

I love rhubarb and used to grow it outside my window in east London.

Luscious lemon, raspberry & rosemary bars

If you’re a lemon-lover you will adore these decadent, keto-friendly, luscious lemon bars studded with succulent raspberries and fragrant rosemary. Beware! – HIGHLY ADDICTIVE :)

Turkish-style eggs, whipped ricotta & brown chilli butter

The magic of warm, runny eggs and cold garlicky ricotta with a spicy kick of bolshy butter will blow your mind. . . So simple but so delicious, a magical dish to impress with ease.

Looking for more recipes?

See all recipes